Jenna is still in love with Toby and not the other way around? Toby is actually innocent and last saw Alison alive? Well . . . that makes our brain do a 180.
We were secretly hoping that Emily would meet up with Toby at the church, but he got another visitor . . . the Rosewood Police. Are they taking away an innocent man?
Do you believe Toby? Or is he full of lies?