Just when we thought “A” couldn’t get any more creepy, we’re proven wrong! Apparently, Rosewood’s ultimate psycho takes everything literally — and when “A” sent the girls a blast about playing with body parts during the Pretty Little Liars Season 3 premiere he/she wasn’t kidding! How so? Because in PLL episode 3.02, “Blood is the New Black” A sends Emily Fields a token of appreciation — a decent homemade necklace or, in less fancy terms, a bunch of human teeth strung together. Sneak a peek at the harrowing scene below!

Yikes! Not only is the new “A” a total sicko, but it sounds like there’s major tension brewing between Aria and Spencer. Oh and Hanna and Spencer! The two girls don’t seem pleased at all with the decision to lie to the cops about being at the lake house when, in actuality, they were in graveyard being framed by “A.” And, once again, poor Emily — she looks broken-down and devastated and rightly so!

So, do you think the teeth are real like Hanna keeps insisting — or are they fakes meant to rattle the girls’ senses? Post your predictions below, and be sure to tune in Tuesday night at 8/7c for an all new Pretty Little Liars Season 3 episode on ABC Family!