Toby Cavanaugh (Keegan Allen) doesn’t know how lucky he has it. He lives in a beautiful town, was born with enviable carpentry skills, boasts a glorious set of abs, and has captured the affections of one of the smartest, most beautiful girls in Rosewood — Spencer Hastings (Troian Bellisario)! If he knew how grand his life actually was, he’d put an end to all his “A” games for good. Unfortunately though, once a creeper always a creeper, and word on the street is that Spencer is going to find out about her BF’s ultimate betrayal in Pretty Little Liars Season 3, Episode 16.
Oh — and before you get too comfortable with that info, just know that it gets worse. How so? Well, you see, PLL episode 3.16 marks Spencer and Toby’s one year anniversary and, in honor of their special day, Spencer recruits her mom to help her plan a scrumptious treat for her blue-eyed boo. Spence is ready to celebrate to the fullest even if that means putting on an apron and baking some lasagna for her man. Unfortunately though, it seems as though the night is going to be unforgettable for reasons other than true love and delicious Italian cuisine.
Watch the “Misery Loves Company” clip below to get a sense of all the sadness to come and feeling of foreboding — and to LOL as Toby makes the situation 100 times more awkward by standing shirtless in front of Veronica Hastings. Then, drop us a note telling us how you think Spencer will react to finding out that her main stud is an “A” team member!