In Pretty Little Liars Season 3, Episode 8, Spencer Hastings enlisted the hacking services of Caleb Rivers, and he was able to break through to Maya St. Germain’s secret website at MAS Sugar. Once on there, they discovered vlogs and videos that Maya had recorded prior to her gruesome murder — some were basically of her professing love for Emily Fields and others were of being creepy (but in a silly way, of course). However, as Spencer, Aria, and Hanna dug deeper into the files they discovered that Maya was a scared girl on the run, and that she was harboring a dark and sinister secret. Unfortunately for viewers worldwide, the Liars decided not to probe any further until they consulted with Emily, who was closet to Maya. But did they actually end up telling Emily? According to an all new clip from episode 3.09 (“The Kahn Game“), the Liars apparently decided to withhold the breaking news from Em…and when Hanna reveals the truth about their sketchy findings, Em’s not too pleased about being lied to.

Preview an intense scene between Hanna and Em from Pretty Little Liars Season 3, Episode 9 below!

Hanna tells Emily that the reason they did not tell her was because they were trying to protect her from the heartache and anguish that the videos would have caused. However, Emily doesn’t think that’s a valid reason reason to lie anyone. So who’s right? YOU tell us! Post your stance on the issue of “it’s always better to tell the truth” in the comments!

Don’t forget to tune in for an exciting new episode of Pretty Little Liars Season 3 this Tuesday night at 8/7 c on ABC Family!