Any way you slice it, there is something weird going on with Toby and Jenna’s relationship. And thanks to the bombshell Toby dropped in “Keep Your Friends Close” we’re even more confused. He said that Jenna didn’t want their ”relationship” to end.
Do you believe Toby? Or was Jenna telling the truth when she said she wanted it to be over?
I believe Toby (:
Toby likes Emily, and I don’t think he would lie to her, and I think Jenna knows more than what she lets on, she may be blind, but that isn’t a disguise…
i believe toby, toby like’s emily and he would not lie to her.
i dont think jenna’s blind at all. The Elevator scene! gosh i hate her!
Same. I dont think Jenna is really blind. She is way too good at it. Anyway, I dont know who to beieve. They are both pretty convincing, but I would have to say Toby.
toby is deffinately not lying. jenna probably did want the relationship to end but was too scared to do anything because she knew he could probably kill her.
Toby is telling the truth!
Jenna seems to know more then she lets out…
I hate that scum!!!!! he DEFINATLY did that to jenna on purpose!!! and SHE wanted it too stop!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! or at least that’s what she told me…………………………………….
i honestly dont know but i think toby wouldnt lie to emily, but isnt he supposed to be dead?? idk. goodness. i just want pretty little liars to be back on and we will find out. grrrrrr!!!!!
Why do we have to wait so long to find out who is the lier? I’m about to go out of my mind lol waiting…waiting…waiting!!! COME ON ALREADY and get to the fall shows! Plz
In the books Jenna told Aria that she and Ali planned it together. So what if Bobbi-Jean is right. What if Jenna isn’t blind. Maybe the books twisted with the show so the only reason Toby gave in was because he didn’t want to keep having sex with Jenna. Jenna is way to laid back and non-careful for a blind person. She was only blind for a year. There is absoloutly no way anyone can be so ready, so fast.
tiby because he likeemily and wouldnt lie to her
@DD Beanie i dont think they were having sex…. in the books toby was just “touching” her sexually. And yea in the books she hated it so her and Ali decided to get rid of Toby.
Also I think Jenna is blind but that might be an interesting twist to the tv show if she isn’t
i belive toby!;)
Considering how popular TV Toby is, I feel pretty certain the writers will make him to be the one who told the truth. I think in the book Toby molested Jenna though.
LMAO at the post title. Now we’ve got the new term “Step-siblings with benefits”.
Honestly, I don’t think Jenna is blind. In the books, yes, but not in the TV show – which is very creepy.
& I do believe Toby – I honestly like him in the show
toby is not lieing jenna is. jenna didn’t want thier ”relatoinship” to end but i think toby did
I believe Toby! I adore him! He likes Emily and doesnt seem like he would lie to her? He seems to have so much trust in Emily & want to be with her kind of thing!
I think Toby was telling the truth and Jenna does know more than she is letting on….Toby probably wanted their relationship to end but Jenna didn’t want to end it…Like in the book,it says he was “touching” her not that they were sleeping together….It sucks that they arrested him while he was waiting on Emily or his ride to leave……I wonder if they are going to put more storylines from the books into the show,I hope so
You can’t believe everything you hear.
-A
How can you believe anything either of them say. You don’t know who’s telling the truth anymore.
I think that Toby is telling the truth because I think Toby changed after that year he left and now that Ali is “gone” then he isn’t as afraid to tell Emily the truth.
i think jenna is telling the truth
Alison Is The Killer!!!!!!!! In The Books It Revealed That Alison Had A Identical Twin Sister Named Courtney Who Was Away At A mental Home So Thye Switched Places But Courtney Became Friends With 4 Losers Which Made Alison Upset But So The Whole Time They Were With Courteney Thinking It Was Alison The REAL Alison Was So Upset That Courtney Ruined Her Life That She Killed Her So The Real Alison Is Alive…MONA Hannahs Wannabe Bestfren Is A. But She Got Killed AS Shown In The Population Change..When She Died The Real Ali Took Her Place AS A…..The Real Alison Was AT Risk Of Dying When The Barn Caught On Fire Ande She Had A SKI Mask ON So When The Girls Took The Log Off Of Her They Seen ALISON..But She Didnt Regonize Them Since She never Knew Them And Thats When They Found Out That Thei Bestfren Was REALLY COURTNEY
I belive Toby, I mean he loves Emily and he wants her to feel the same way so I dont think he would lie to her. And he is really popular on the show, people like Emily and Toby more then Emily and Maya. So I dont think the writers are going to make him the bad guy, they were planning on it at first but he became a loved character. They will make it look like he is a bad guy but he’s not, Keegan(Toby) even said Toby turns out to be not such a bad guy. Besides Jenna is way creepier than Toby, and for only being blind for a year she really seems like she has been blind for years.
i am reading the books and i just finished book 4, Unbelievable, and Jenna told Aria that Ali and her planed Jenna’s acedent so i am siding with Jenna
i think those bitchesss better watch out they are being watched o and ali is she really dead is anyone who they say they are
kisses
And is emily a cheater oh no i gave it away maya better watch out Im going to get her two kisses
I love playing games with people its so fun they don’t know crap I swear you pretty little liars fans better watch out Im watching you to and it ain’t going to be funny when your secrets come out and you die all alone in a hole because i know where you live and i watch you do your stuff you guys arent innocent but i am better watch out b***ches im going to get you
i beleive toby he wouldnt lie to emily and i think it was stupid of emily for doing what she did to toby
i belive toby he realy likes em and wouldnt lie to her and what she did to him was so stupid
@DyNish Why Do You Type Like This With Capitals At The Beginning Of Every Word?
I have read all the books too. But they are changing alot of stuff so It will be surprising.
i luv pll they rock
Okay so i’m soo confused! and Jenna is not blind!!
OMG I’m sooo confused he says he wanted it to end but didn’t he started it and personally I think Jenna is blind she just has killer senses
toby is telling the truth
and i have this crazy theory. maybe alison is live and jena isnt, maybe alison killed jena and change her color hair and used the glasses to cover her real eye color which is blue, jena’s eyes are green,and the same colour lipstick just a crazy theory
im in the middle of unbelievable and with the whole jenna isnt blind thing… i kinda started believing that too but then today in science we were talking about senses and my teacher said if you cancel one in this case seeing, all of the other senses get stronger so i dont know what to believe anymore!
YALL ALL WRONG . . . . .. when the firework hit jenna before that toby was touching her they reviele that in flawless the book in orange duh get the facts straight
Guys, jenna really is blind. read the books! ,ali and jenna had planned to set the firework off so that toby would get in trouble and get sent a away . but everything went wrong. Btw mona is A! (:
I thought it was already revealed that the identity of “A” is different from the books. But I’m 99% sure Jenna is blind. There have been people who are “creepy” in their own way but it would be too stupid if she ended up as the mastermind.
i dont even know wat to think anymor!! AHHHHH!!! umm it said that jenna looked terrified so i guess wen toby wanted to stop she was relieved but confused. was she not good enof for her anymor? was ther somthin wrong wit her? maybe she confessed this to toby and it came off as her not wanting it to end. idk
I believe Toby naturally! =) He likes Emily and wouldn’t lie to her!
Confusedddd is meeee! :’(
update from pretty little liars toby to begin with is hot anyway he is with spencer now and of course he is telling the truth
and i kno who A is
Thank you, DyNisha. You are very, very considerate for putting 19 spoilers (I counted) and no “SPOILER ALERT FROM WANTED. The show is different from the books. Face it. Still, you shouldn’t have used all the pointless spoilers because some people (not including me) have not finished the books. Oh, and by the way, please learn to type.