Toby & Jenna: Very Creepy!

  Sara Shepard’s second Pretty Little Liars novel, Flawless, reveals something creepy and unexpected about Toby’s relationship with his step-sister, Jenna. It’s an amazing twist that leaves readers—and Emily—unsure about which Cavanaugh to trust. If you haven’t read Flawless yet, … Continue reading

Step-Siblings With Benefits

Any way you slice it, there is something weird going on with Toby and Jenna’s relationship. And thanks to the bombshell Toby dropped in “Keep Your Friends Close” we’re even more confused.  He said that Jenna didn’t want their ”relationship” to end. Do you believe Toby? Or was Jenna telling the … Continue reading