Who is “A”? Suspects Based on Pretty Little Liars Season 3, Episode 1

Well, the cat’s out of the bag…there’s a new “A” in Rosewood and he/she is more vengeful, ruthless, and twisted than Mona Vanderwaal, Klaus Mikaelsen, and Bellatrix Lestrange combined! Hanna, Emily, Spencer, and Aria realized the A games were far from over when they received a spine-tingling text message at the end of Pretty Little Liars Season 3, Episode 1. (Apparently, the new “A” likes human body parts as opposed to dolls like Mona.) So who could this new and improved psycho be? Take a peek at our top “Who is A?” five suspects based on “It Happened That Night”!

Wren Kim

Did it strike anyone as odd that Wren was doing pro bono work? First of all, as practically the only doctor in Rosewood, where does he find the time? Second, it's awfully convenient that he happens to be paying it forward at the exact institution that the first "A" is wasting her days away? Third, he randomly had Hanna's number and called her like it was no big deal. Um, only an "A" suspect would do that!

Lucas Gottesman

Creeping around Rosewood late at night? Check. Acting like Boo Radley? Check. Looking around warily and not smiling hello at Hanna at school? Check. Lucas is up to something and for all we know we may be in cahoots with the town's new phantom menace!

Spencer Hastings

Whenever a Liar disappears, Spencer always seems to be separated from the group. First it was Alison in PLL Season 1 and most recently it was Emily. She's smart enough to figure out how to stalk people without getting caught and she's creative enough to conjure up revenge tactics. The only thing that leaves her in the clear is the fact that she wasn't the one who killed Ian Thomas and she couldn't be the black swan from the dance...since she was too busy hanging with the real A, Mona! Time will only tell if we can 100% trust Spencer or not.

Toby Cavanaugh

We love Toby, don't get us wrong. But there's still something highly off about him. He has motive for getting even with Alison and the Liars and, even though he's all lovey dovey with Spencer, he could just be embracing the old adage "keep your friends close but your enemies closer." We hope it's not the case because Toby rocks but for now all we can do is keep an eye on him for any unusual behavior!

Alison DiLaurentis

Sure, in PLL episode 3.01 she was merely a figment of Mona Vanderwaal's imagination...or was she really? In the books, Alison had a twin. Could the same twist be taking place on the show? Also, check out her book -- again with the Lolita. Is Alison supplying a clue about the new "A" (in the event that she's actually dead and it isn't her)? Hmm.

Who is your A today based on the PLL Season 3 premiere?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Who do you think the new A in Pretty Little Liars Season 3 is? Post your prediction in the comments!


  1. VargasH Said:

    spencer said the same exact words as when alison went missing and to think that the call was from her cell phone …

  2. Theo Said:

    @VargasH So eerie!

  3. Pingback: Pretty Little Liars Source • • Your Largest & Best Online Resource for Everything Pretty Little Liars

  4. Naomi Said:

    I think Alison is the new “A” and maybe it could also be her twin. There is no way it could be Toby, Wren, or Spencer!

  5. MeAmSmiley Said:

    Spencer was gone when The Emily Thing happened she could have been gone way longer than we thought. Keep your friends close but your enemies closer. The liars are close to her more than anything. She could be with the A team. When MonA asked Spencer to be on the A TEAM she could have answered her and it wasn’t no. You got to exspect the unexspected. That’s my guess.

  6. DivinA Said:

    well…It better not be Spencer!!!I don’t care if it’s anyone else(among th 5 of coz..but not her coz I’d probably stop watching!but I think dat Wren is way too cute 2 b A

  7. spencerhfan0612 Said:

    There’s no way it’s Spencer. That would be really dumb to make one of the four girls A. But as for her mom and sister… who knows? I think it may be Alison.

  8. smileyailie Said:

    It IS alison! Remember the Halloween episode? When Alison tells the story about the twin killing the other twin?? What a coincidink! Foreshadowing,,, plus they wouldnt just put that in there for no reason…

  9. Muireann Said:

    i kinda think its aria…

  10. Eva Said:


  11. dimitri Said:

    I think its allison or wren they look so sucpicous -dimitri rousse

  12. Marie Said:

    the possible suspects for “A” have something in common, their names all end with an “a”. For example MonA, JennA, MelissA, CeceliA (Cece Drake), EzrA, MayA. It may be a coincidence but that is something i picked up on.

  13. Kaylan Said:

    Warning spoiler: Mona is The first A,I don’t know who the second is, but unexpectedly Toby is the third A to protect spencer. Cece ends up being the big A though.

Leave a Reply



Characters Remaining